The Island
Ewan McGregor does his usual fine job as a man who thinks who knows who he is, but then discovers his identity is not what it appeared to be. McGregor makes a fine action hero, but gives a better performance in the ’slow’ sections of the film. He appears to be more comfortable in these scenes than in the big action ones. Scarlett Johansson is quite good in her first action role, and gives her role a subtle charm amid all the chaos that follows. Sean Bean makes an arresting villain and chews the scenery as only he can. Steve Buscemi turns up as a worker in the colony, and gives his usual hammy performance. The rest of the cast do what they can with the material, but once the explosions start, the body count goes up and the quality of the performances goes down!
Mention must be made of the production design of the film, which is fantastic. Most of the costumes that the survivors wear are all white, which goes with the white decor in the place they live in. This gives the film a very stark look - although it must be said, it does add to the cliché that is found in most sci fi films that the future is either bright or a dark grungy place. The story in the film is quite interesting, with a few surprises, but once the explosions start, plot and pacing go out the window, and it essentially becomes a very long chase film. In the hands of a better director, this could have been quite an intelligent film. As it is, this is basically a popcorn entertainment movie for undiscriminating types.
Rating out of 10: 5
Sin City
The cast assembled for this are veterans of previous Rodriguez films, plus some new faces. Bruce Willis gives an excellent performance as the hard bitten cop who tries to stay clean of corruption and actually enforce the law properly. Jessica Alba infuses her part with innocence and grace, which is crucial for her role. Mickey Rourke is almost unrecognisable as Marv, wearing a ton of make up, but giving the role a driving energy as he tries to bring the killers to justice. Elijah Wood is very creepy as the mute assassin, making him very unpredictable and deadly. Clive Owen manages to capture the spirit of pulp detectives from classic films and makes his role as the world weary PI a good one. The rest of the cast includes Josh Harnett, Brittany Murphy, Bennicio Del Toro, and Nick Stahl, who are all good in their parts.
This is at times a very tough, violent and gritty film, with interlocking stories which moves the timeframe around to add impact. For example, one character may die in the first half of the film, but turn up alive in the second half. At times, the story does meander a bit, and seems to lose it’s momentum towards the end. The best ones in the film are Bruce Willis and Clive Owen, who seem to fit in perfectly with the film noir style.
Not quite as good as previous Robert Rodriguez films, although definitely one worth catching for the visual style, which has been rarely seen before. ‘Sin City’ brings to life a comic book in a unique and interesting way.
Rating out of 10: 7 and a half