Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close

Adapted from Jonathan Safran Foer’s novel, Director Stephen Daldry’s new work has received mixed views.  Based on the September 11 attacks its emotive subject matter has been seen as a ploy for garnering Awards.  Whilst it has indeed been nominated for many glittering prizes, its main reason for existing should be to stimulate the mind and soul.  That it mostly doesn’t is a fault of an unclear narrative smothering its good intentions.

September 11 2001 is a day young Oskar (Thomas Horn) will never forget.  Discovering his beloved father Thomas (Tom Hanks) was one of the victims of that day’s attacks, he tries to discover why this happened.  His grief stricken mother Linda (Sandra Bullock) is unable to provide answers setting him on a quest to uncover his own.  Finding a key hiding in a vase in his father’s wardrobe, little does he know it will unearth a familial mystery.  Helped by a mysterious stranger (Max Von Sydow) the journey he embarks forever changes him.


Occasionally having flashes of genuine pathos, ‘Extremely Loud’ almost fails on every other level.  The main reason is the depiction of Oskar’s autism.  It isn’t particularly established enough to allow understanding of his behaviour.  At times he comes across as being irritatingly rude to those doing their best to help him.  This isn’t the fault of Horn - who plays him well - it just makes it very difficult to join such an unlikeable character on his travels.


Other characters fare no better and never really contribute much to the overall story.  Von Sydow’s role is a good example as his role serves little purpose in changing Oskar’s viewpoint.  Having an overly melodramatic tone with swirling violins highlighting Oskar’s troubles doesn’t help either even if the conclusion is reasonably satisfying.  It’s a struggle reaching that point however with the production only the sum of its parts.


Told in an artificially confected manner, ‘Extremely Loud’ never really amounts to much.  Although involving in some places its coldness in conveying its story decreases any of its noble intentions.


Rating out of 10:  5

No Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post. | TrackBack URI
You can also bookmark this on del.icio.us or check the cosmos

« Gone    Contraband »